A few days ago had a census worker knock on my door. I thought the purpose of census was for representation purposes. Asking for federal money or federal representation is a huge mistake. The census is unconstitutional - read the enumerations - and the amendments already cited. However, because the government has not brought a prosecution for a refusal to respond to the ACS, the question of a persons right to refuse has not yet been decided by a court. answers to this "anonymous" survey, my information would necessarily be identifiable, perhaps through my address, for at least some period of time. Nothing illegal about that! Copyright 2023 The Rutherford Institute. I'll give you potential issues with being counted. Helping this corrupt government "function" is the same thing as helping this corrupt government go kill more people, invade our privacy, tax our income, levy fines, issue permissions slips and tattoo our butts. Millions of dollars wasted! For these reasons and likely more, the ACS has been said to be unanswered by about 45% of its recipients. My hubby has served this country for over 30 years, we are about to retire and what a lovely retirement gift we are receiving (NOT)!.Harassment, compliments of the government, just lovely (NOT). "I'm afraid my trees are eating the elephants, now." Typically, the Census Bureau will telephone those who do not respond to the survey and may visit their homes to coerce the targets to respond. I just don't answer the door. My son answered the door, the guy announced who he was with. Make your own mind up as to what your world should be -- it's that simple. Objections to the ACS include the personal nature of some of its questions and, despite government assurances to the contrary, associated confidentiality issues. He gave his name and the number of people living here and refused to answer anything else. I ignored all of this due to what I had been through. The less you say to them the faster they stop bothering you. Someone said they can find all our info on the internet anyway. The Census Bureau boasts a 97% response rate to the survey via these methods,[34] but critics argue this constitutes harassment. I can just feature a call stating: If you can't walk up and down stairs, maybe we should think about asking if you are a useful citizen and do you need to be wandering around loose. any lawyers looking for some pro bono work ready to take up this issue? I say, "I don't care who you are. She noticed that I was very irritated and told me that she just needs the number of people who live here and ages. But I hit the brakes big time when they ask for your birthdate, among other garbage of race, sex, etc. If you had a wife who had been sexually assaulted, would you want the time you left for and came home from work circulated? Q: Has the government prosecuted persons for refusing to answer the American Community Survey? If they come and announce who they are, I'll simply start yelling, "Non parlo Inglese! We filled in very basic info and did put in the drive times. By their asking their questions (limited to how many people live here) you have "met" your legal obligation to the Census. It gives a little glimmer of hope for this country. 2018] IN DEFENSE OF THE AMERICAN COMMUNITY SURVEY 113 surveys.18 After the 2000 Census, the Bureau chose to eliminate the long form and use a yearly survey instead.19 In 2006, the Bureau fully implemented the ACS throughout the United States.20 The ACS is now conducted yearly, and includes much of the same data requested by the 2000 long form.21 In . Keep your cool and you'll be fine. When the government fears the people there is liberty." Best wishes, and see you all after the election. Where do we call to report this abuse? Other than that, the sky is the limit. American Community Survey 2021? - Blogs & Forums - QVC Today another call demanding to know my name and telling me I would be fined. We've tossed two surveys in the recycle bin. The court agreed with the defendants contention that courts have consistently considered unripe for review cases wherein there was no specific threat of enforcement or history of prosecution under the relevant statutes.. Actually: for thoe who think you can merely fill out the form and not be called, that's a lie! Unless an individual has been charged and convicted of some criminal offense connected to the Census and the crime falls within section 3559, this $5,000.00 fine does not apply. I have therefore included both Article 1 section 2 of the US Constitution, and the US Supreme courts decisions in upholding the right to privacy. First time around it ended with phone calls and then they I was given a $25 gift card at the Home Depot. I suppose if they have the info to redistrict, they have all the info they need. I just sent the supervisor who knocked on my door packing! Since then I have been visited a few times by a nice Dept. Has anyone else who refused to comply have any information about penalties/fines actually being enforced to date? I am so glad I found this website. "Um, I filled it out twice". I put up with some minor harassment and then after a few weeks it stopped. Why don't you post the number in your family, their names, ethnic profile, give us your address and then, we will consider giving merit to your post. First survey last month. If that's so, why is there a space for your name, date of birth and so much other identifying information that a blind man could identify the author of the answers. I am getting bothered by the census people now and what really annoys me to death is that I look all over the place and see all these people with basement apartments making tons of money off the books. EXCLUDE State operated juvenile residential facilities. It is the premier source for detailed population and housing information about our nation. i love my country and its freedom and its up to us to keep the communism out!! The data bank, like any data bank, runs the risk of being hacked or accessed by dishonest parties. You can search the internet and find many references to threats of a fine, but you won't find anyone who has ever been fined. While I also oppose the Census form being sent out, -anon70698, the number of representatives and taxes will be determined by the number of people in the area is what Article I, Section 2, Clause 3 of the United States Constitution is about. I wonder how many of those opposing census questions will annually volunteer much more private information and their personal wealth to a real evil unconstitutional organization - the IRS. At first I thought this was the census under another name, then as I read it I could not believe how invasive it was. Cowards! When I saw the personal and invasive nature of recent Census, I was irate. What you say is true. its no joke. When they arrive on your property, order them off your property. If people answer the survey maybe they will get the funding to have proper educational programs. I can not believe this is United States, land of freedom and liberty. How Banks Can Serve Customers with Language Barriers PDF [From the ACS recipient to the Census Bureau] John H. Thompson As said by Mr. Justice Field in Re Pacific Ry. If you got grilled before then they are trying to find out the change in your situation over time. He was shocked and said it was required by law. [12] https://www2.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/about/qbyqfact/2016/Fertility.pdf. I hope this helps. Since then, they have called three or four times and stopped by multiple times. Get over yourselves! They want me to call an 800 number to give them my personal info. This is such an invasion of privacy. The Census Act of 1976 specifically prohibits the use of statistical sampling in the creation of congressional districts. Oh, the reason he came back? Now whenever we come home, Ms. Nosy Neighbor calls a different census worker who hurries over and tries to get us to answer the door. Ultimately, you might just need to either answer the census to get them to stop coming or, as an alternative, make up answers to protect your privacy. The calls/personal visits stopped. I have no problem filling out the main census form but not this BS. anon10731 is obviously a census worker!!!!!! How come I get the ACS? Good luck everyone! She left me with a notice of visit with her name and I suppose her personal phone number. Why doesn't the gov just sell us some cyanide instead of slowly picking away at our bones? 3) If by some chance they go for it, ask them the most embarrassing, asinine, or silly questions you can think of. Its as if this part of the government wants to create dirt on someone if they can find it! I was mailed two ACS forms which I promptly threw in the trash because of the personal nature of the questions. [33] Gardner Selby, Americans Must Answer U.S. Census Bureau Survey by Law, Though Agency Hasn't Prosecuted since 1970, Politifact, http://www.politifact.com/texas/statements/2014/jan/09/us-census-bureau/americans-must-answer-us-census-bureau-survey-law-/. Today I received a notice in the mail from the Census Bureau Director, Robert M. Groves, advising me that next week I'll receive a 2010 Census form in the mail and would I fill it out and mail it in promptly. This browser does not support PDFs. Finally a man identifying himself as a supervisor came to the door and demanded I answer. A: The ACS contains questions that go far beyond typical census questions about the number of individuals within the household and their age, race, and sex. While talking to the ACS lady on the phone I found out they didn't have a complete address and had sent me a form. Three times they were soaked standing at my door. Mailed it in. You can't actually expect all of the decisions to be made accurately and take into account the needs at the consumer level based on a head county every 10 years. I set it aside. Anyway, this guy knocked twice or three time so I ignored him. If you read and listen to them carefully they actually say that it's mandatory and you could be fined. The Institute provides its legal services at no charge to persons whos constitutional and human rights have been threatened or violated. I also ignored the mailed survey. I started to take the survey and the more I saw the more upset I got. I want to put it in the woodstove and make my house a fortress. About one month later I received a phone call from a supervisor. Then they came to my door while I was out of town and left me a note with their name and number. In three weeks they should mail me a duplicate form. The American Community Survey is conducted by the U.S. Census Bureau. If threatened with a fine or even prison, I will say, "Bring it on!" This is Government out of control. I didnt think so. Is the 'American Community Survey' Letter a Scam or Legit? At that point I stepped in and said goodbye. Well, I will just have to wait for the "or else" because I will not be a robot for this government, asking when I go to work or who are all the females in my house with ages and names. When I got to the financial questions I thought - what?? [31] https://www.census.gov/programs-surveys/acs/about/survey-is-mandatory.html. I will pay the fine if that is what it takes. A concerned citizen. Well they stopped today. In the current study . I live in the ghetto already. I like the idea of video taping them and guess I will charge up the old video camera. Anyone else with other info/advice is politely requested to add their two cents. Would I really be fined or imprisoned? The census is not going to do this or that. Don't you think someone high up already has their * in a wringer over that? Wow! American Community Survey (ACS) | Department of Finance We were hired to call people who did not respond and we left messages on answering machines. These "enumerators" aren't policemen and they can't make you answer their questions or let them into your house. ), vacated sub nom. I will not submit. [34] http://www.sciencemag.org/news/2015/04/will-kinder-gentler-census-survey-placate-congressional-foes. How many times has this person been married? This survey is intrusive and i will not answer it! No one from the Census has ever called you every hour of the day or at 9 p.m. I hope my great-grandkids appreciate it, too. Thus, if they want a specific task force to track illegals and tax invading americans, then so be it. He said he'd pass that along. Perhaps act so insanely crazy they will be glad to leave. Fiscal Year 2024 Letter to OMB Director Shalanda Young encouraging the Administration to prioritize funding for the U.S. Census Bureau and 2030 Census in its FY 2024 The US Census Bureau says it's an essential tool in collecting relevant and timely data in order to understand and finance local needs for things like roads and schools. When I said I would not be probed by his questions from the government and continued by saying that I meant no disrespect to him; however, I hate what the government is trying to do to us he responded. We already did our duty and answered the regular census. (We filled out and mailed our census form as soon as we received it.) don't let them take our rights away even more than they already have. She was a little surprised how I knew things about her. The US government already has all the information they need on people who file their annual income tax. I answered only the necessary information on the first census, then was mailed the ever intrusive ACS. The old surveys don't ask for much more than that (other than birthplace). The American Community Survey (ACS) qualifies as a government program whose purpose, while seemingly benign, raises significant constitutional concerns. 2d 570, 572 (N.D. That's when I lost my patience and said "Look pal, you're here to count people right. The SS Admin does not care. The next day I saw this guy talking to my neighbor and figured he was submitting him to the same harassment I had received. Thesis: It is best to be professional and courteous when speaking in person and on the phone to the ACS representatives. Does anyone know? I needed to read this! The yahoos on the Hill will continue to usurp our rights. But please do not chastise me for maintaining my personal and family privacy and refusing to respond to an unconstitutional intrusion into my personal affairs. That didn't go over to well and he told me that I was refusing to comply with a government agency and wouldn't get my money back. And no one can say with a high degree of certainty whether the virus was the result of . That this money is funding from the government, which makes it socialism. Yeah right! Release Calendar Top 250 Movies Most Popular Movies Browse Movies by Genre Top Box Office Showtimes & Tickets Movie News India Movie Spotlight. Whether I'm white, black, hispanic, etc., or whether I own or rent my home, makes as much difference to the count of legal U.S. citizens as not having to show your legal or illegal status as a U.S. citizen. To sign up for updates please enter your email address. I would like to inform all participants that your lines have been placed on a listen-only mode until the question-and-answer session of today's call. No need to respond to the intrusive survey. We keep refusing them and they keep threatening us. He asked if I was refusing to answer the survey. You are! Then you've got them by the balls. Another concern raised by the Brookings Institute is the use of ACS information by law enforcement for crime mapping, a surveillance tool used to predict crime and preemptively target certain neighborhoods for policing. I've been harassed by phone at night and Sundays. I guess we'll just wait and see. Low-Income Renters Spent Larger Share of Income on Rent in 2021 * Compared to other measured TV manufacturers in the 2022 American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI) survey of customers. A Census Bureau representative is quoted in this report as saying that the Bureau is really not in the business of prosecuting people who dont comply.[33] However, a refusal to answer the survey violates the letter of the law and a prosecution might be brought if the government decides to adopt a policy to do so. i am not in their rat race, and i do not answer to their color coded political designations. Polite, firm, refusal. I am a tax paying, hard working citizen, who would die fighting for my country and my rights, but didn't our forefathers already settle this fight? this stupid stupid government and all its crap we have been harassed over and over and over and today again. In the case of direct taxes (a direct tax is a tax on property based on ownership), this provision requires Congress to apportion the tax among the individual States based on population. There are friends who ask me if I want to put up with the harassment from the government -wouldn't it be easier to just give in and give the information to them? After reading through the 28 pages of questions the second time (not 28 questions but 28 *pages* of them), I decided to do my research. I wish you luck. I am looking into who passed legislation to approve this questionnaire. The last thing the execs at the Census Bureau want to see is a video of one of their "enumerators" on YouTube, the Six O'clock News, or in Congress or a courtroom harassing and threatening a citizen/voter with a big fine or jail time if that person refuses to give out the personal details of his life to a perfect stranger. I ignored her as I was outside with my kids. Measuring America's People, Places, and Economy. I didn't hear from them for about two weeks. the government was never constitutionally mandated to provide funds. They have nothing but their own agenda in mind and any semblance of control we think we have is just that -- a semblance. Like many, I received the original short census form, completed it and mailed it back immediately. Tells the stories behind the numbers in a new inviting way. ACS was conducted vigorously and continuously during the presidency of George W. Bush. Access American Community Survey data on the Census Bureau's new platform, data.census.gov. No, they aren't good people just trying to make a living as some might say. I finally left a voice mail for the person who kept calling me that if I got one more call or personal visit, I was contacting my state senator and tell him I was being harassed. Way too much info requested (stuff I wouldn't tell my friends, let alone the government!!) 1,1 descussion - homework - Currently, Oscar is a 7-year-old boy with We have received phone calls. The founders feared the use of direct taxes so they created a system to discourage their use. Read the Constitution. Actual enumeration is required. I made the decision right then and there that I would not respond to an ACS survey under any circumstances.
Can Deer Eat Almonds,
Gainesville Sun Obituaries Today,
Sheet Metal Workers Local Unions And Councils Pension Fund,
Articles A